For an Old Fashioned, finding the finest bourbon for the drink is more difficult than you may imagine. It's not as simple as locating the greatest bourbon, purchasing it, and then mixing an Old Fashioned with it to produce the best one ever.
Yes, the quality of the bourbon is critical. For an old fashioned, choosing the finest bourbon for your budget, taste, how practical you want to be, and personal preference are all important considerations.
A word of caution before we get into the top bourbons for an Old Fashioned: I don't think it's a good idea to use a pricey bourbon in this drink (or any other cocktail for that matter). You won't find anything above $50 on this list, as a result. In order to create an Old Fashioned, I would not spend more than $50 on a bourbon. I don't think it's worth it to spend more than that on anything else (and money). The greatest bourbons for an Old Fashioned are out there, but it's crucial that you know how to create one first.
It should go without saying that great bourbon is essential in an Old Fashioned, maybe even more so than in other cocktails. But where do you begin when there are so many different bourbons to choose from? Following some study, we came up with this list of the best Bourbons to use in an Old Fashioned drink. We hope you like it!
If you're seeking for high-quality bourbon that's also simple to get by, go no further. Most importantly, our list of the top Old Fashioned-enhancing spirits is the most important element of our guide. If you're looking for the ideal Old Fashioned, go no further than this list of the best bourbons available.
1. Buffalo Trace
Buffalo Trace Bourbon is produced in the most award-winning distillery in the world, the Buffalo Trace Distillery. Everything you could wish for in a high-quality, reasonably priced bourbon is there in this whiskey: the best ingredients and a well-crafted maturation procedure combine to create a robust spirit with rich and nuanced smells.
Buffalo Trace has created a real work of art in the process of doing so. The bourbon's distinctive blend of tastes, which include vanilla, mint, molasses, toffee, dark fruit, and anise, make it a good match for an Old Fashioned. This top-tier spirit is a bourbon that everyone should sample at least once throughout their lives. You will not be disappointed.
2. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
A unique approach to twice-barreled whiskey, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked delivers a rich and vibrant taste unlike any other bourbon on the market. After being aged in handmade new white oak barrels for the first time, Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is then creatively aged for a second time in another new barrel, resulting in a whiskey that is unlike any other. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked is a smooth, full-bodied bourbon with a long, rich finish that is highly toasted before being lightly charred, resulting in the distinct characteristics of Woodford Reserve Double Oaked.
This spirit is already a touch harsh to begin with, so it will need some more assistance in the form of sugar or simple syrup in order to be drinkable again. Otherwise, the bitterness in the glass is just too much.
The tastes, on the other hand, are fantastic in general. With the addition of that extra sweetness, the cocktail becomes rather pleasant, and the additional vanilla and oak tastes of the liquor blend well with the orange peel and other fruity notes in the drink.
3. Bulleit Bourbon
it is a whiskey produced by Bulleit & Company. Bulleit Straight Bourbon has a distinct and intriguing flavor profile that is ideal for individuals who want to be able to enjoy a superb old fashioned with a twist. Because it is infused with both black pepper and ginger, this bourbon will assist you in creating an old fashioned that is packed with spicy tastes.
One of the characteristics that distinguish Bulleit Bourbon is that it is prepared with a significant proportion of rye in the mash bill. Thus, the pepper notes found in classic rye whiskey are enhanced, while the smooth and mellow flavors of vanilla and caramel corn found in a bourbon are brought out to play.
4. Hayden's Bourbon
Hayden's Bourbon is a stand-alone bourbon that may be enjoyed straight, on the rocks, or gloriously in an Old Fashioned cocktail, among other things. It's a bourbon that's been spiked with rye, so it's a little peppery. Aside from that, the rich fragrant notes of honey, peppermint, and citrus wrap the senses, greeting your taste receptors as if they were an old friend.
Rarely does such a one-of-a-kind mix of quality and craftsmanship present itself in a manner that leaves you questioning, "Why haven't I had this experience before?" One tiny batch of Basil Hayden's whiskey is meticulously matured and bottled at 80 proof, making it a rare find. However, don't misinterpret the fact that it exists as an indication of a calm disposition. This bourbon, on the other hand, is strong and flavorful.
When you take your first drink, you'll wonder who was asleep at the wheel when the price was set. At this pricing range, there are few other rye-infused bourbons that can compete with Basil Hayden's excellence. For those searching for a wonderful complement to their Old Fashioned recipe, this is a spirit that should not be overlooked. What really is holding you back? The price of a bottle of Basil Hayden's Kentucky Straight Bourbon is around $45 USD.
5. Elijah Craig's "Small Batch" is a collection of his work.
In honor of Elijah Craig, a Baptist preacher who resided in Kentucky during the nineteenth century and is commonly regarded as the "Father of Bourbon," Elijah Craig Bourbon is named after him. In keeping with history, this whiskey is a genuinely superb bourbon at the price that it is being offered.
Elijah Craig is a small batch bourbon that is distilled, aged, and bottled in Kentucky. It is made from a traditional Bourbon mash bill of 78 percent corn, 10 percent rye, and 12 percent malted barley, and it is aged for 8 to 12 years in new American oak barrels with a third of the char removed from the barrels. As a consequence, each batch is distinctive while being dependably sweet and smooth. The undertones of vanilla, caramel, and fruit in Elijah Craig bourbon round out the flavor profile perfectly. Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon has a suggested retail price of $35 per bottle.
6. Old Forester Prohibition-Era Bourbon (Old Forester 1920)
The Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon is the third release in the Old Forester Whiskey Row line, after the first and second releases. "Celebrates the brand's continuous distillation throughout Prohibition," says the label, which refers to the time when Old Forester was given a permission to continue distilling on Louisville's Whiskey Row.
On the nose, this Whiskey has a powerful presence, with beautifully strong notes of cherry, caramel, and bittersweet chocolate. The palate is densely packed with sweet caramel, nuttiness, and cedar flavors. The end is acidic and Smokey, with a long lingering smoky aftertaste. Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon sells for around $50 per bottle on the market.
7. Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
This is New York's original bourbon, brewed from 100 percent maize cultivated in the state and matured in tiny barrels to bring out the boldest flavor. With a sweet, caramel-meets-vanilla flavor, it's just the sort of whiskey that complements an Old Fashioned well. Sweet appreciates the "huge intensity" of the wine and the way it "lingers for a long" on the tongue after each sip, according to him. Using two ounces Hudson Baby Bourbon to half an ounce simple syrup, he pours the mixture into a "ice glacier" that swiftly cools the spirit down to the proper temperature.
8. Eagle Rare 10 Year
While Buffalo Trace (Distillery) produces a wide range of excellent bourbons, "the stuff they hold around and pick for a single barrel after 10 years is always extremely fulfilling," says experts of this limited edition bottling of Buffalo Trace bourbon. "It’s sweet and toasty tastes are very delectable." Another benefit is that "the quality is top-notch, yet the pricing is far
cheaper than you'd expect." As a result, you shouldn't be hesitant to use it into a drink. In expert’s opinion, "it's a fantastic match for an Old Fashioned," since the woody overtones are prominent.
9. Woodford Reserve Wheat Whiskey
we point out, "You may get some menthol notes on wheated whiskies that give them an extra sharpness, which is a high note in an Old Fashioned," he adds. "What I enjoy about wheated bourbons is the fresh-herb taste," says the author. A flowery and fruity bouquet is delivered by this bottle, thanks to the presence of wheat in the mash bill (52%).